Sponsored
Rent or Buy Blockbuster Hits
Maggie Moore(s)
Full Movie·2023·1h 39m·en
A

Maggie Moore(s)

Dive into the darkly comedic world of Maggie Moore(s), where a small-town police chief finds himself investigating two bizarre murders—both victims sharing the same name. It’s a twisty mystery that pulls in a nosy neighbor, leading to unexpected connections and plenty of laughs.

Watch on Amazon Prime Video with AdsStreaming

Where to watch

Available on 10 services

Showing availability for US (17 options). Streaming options change frequently — verify on the platform itself before purchasing.

Watch Trailer

Streaming availability data updates regularly. Verify the platform listing before purchasing.

Share:
Sponsored
Rent or Buy Blockbuster Hits

Top cast

7 people
MO

Movie OTT Editorial

6 min read · Published May 26, 2026

6.1/10

Unraveling the Double Mystery of Maggie Moore(s)

In the seemingly quiet, sun-baked landscape of a small Arizona town, Police Chief Jordan Sanders (Jon Hamm) finds his routine dramatically shattered by a perplexing double homicide. Two women, both named Maggie Moore, are found dead under mysterious circumstances, launching Sanders into an investigation that quickly reveals a tangled web of local secrets and lies. As he tries to piece together the bizarre connections between the two victims, he crosses paths with Rita (Tina Fey), a sharp-witted and undeniably nosy neighbor who, despite her gossipy tendencies, becomes an unexpected confidante. This darkly comedic crime mystery, Maggie Moore(s), sets the stage for a compelling blend of humor and suspense, where every resident seems to have something to hide, and the truth is buried deep beneath the desert dust.

The Creative Minds Behind Maggie Moore(s): Slattery, Hamm, and Fey

Maggie Moore(s), a 2023 American black comedy mystery, marks a significant collaboration for its lead stars and director. The film was helmed by John Slattery, best known for his acting roles in Mad Men (where he worked extensively with Jon Hamm) and Veep, showcasing his talent behind the camera once again. The screenplay, a darkly humorous and intricate narrative, was penned by Paul Bernbaum, weaving a tale that feels both familiar and unsettlingly unique. The film boasts a stellar ensemble cast, with Jon Hamm taking on the central role of Police Chief Sanders, bringing his signature blend of gravitas and understated wit to the character. Opposite him, Tina Fey shines as Rita, the inquisitive neighbor whose observations often cut through the small-town facade. The supporting cast includes strong performances from Micah Stock, Nick Mohammed, Happy Anderson, Louisa Krause, and Mary Holland, each adding their own distinct flavor to the film's quirky world. Interestingly, the narrative itself draws inspiration from real-life events, being loosely based on the tragic and baffling murders of Mary Lou Morris and Mary McGinnis Morris, which occurred in October 2000 in Houston, Texas. This real-world anchor gives the film a chilling undercurrent, despite its comedic leanings. Released with an R rating, Maggie Moore(s) isn't afraid to tackle mature themes and language, fitting its dark comedy genre. Critically, the film received a mixed reception, scoring a Metascore of 43 out of 100, indicating generally unfavorable reviews, while Rotten Tomatoes gave it a 51% "Rotten" rating. However, audiences on IMDb were slightly more forgiving, giving it a 6.2/10 based on 10,443 votes. As Movie OTT tracks, films with this kind of critical-audience split often find their true following on streaming platforms. Honestly, the buzz around Hamm and Fey reuniting from their 30 Rock days was palpable. Variety reported that "the reunion of Jon Hamm and Tina Fey, even in a darker comedic setting, was a major draw for audiences and a key talking point for the film's marketing."

The Darkly Comedic Heart and Mixed Reception of Maggie Moore(s)

What makes Maggie Moore(s) an intriguing watch, despite its mixed critical scores, is its audacious embrace of dark comedy amidst a grim murder mystery. The film deftly uses the small-town setting to amplify its comedic elements, showcasing a community where everyone knows everyone's business—or thinks they do. Hamm’s portrayal of Chief Sanders is a masterclass in deadpan, a weary lawman trying to make sense of the senseless, while Fey's Rita is a whirlwind of well-meaning interference, her nosy neighbor instincts often stumbling upon crucial clues by accident. Their chemistry? Undeniable. The movie isn't just about solving a crime; it’s about the absurdity of human behavior, the secrets people keep, and the unexpected connections forged under pressure. I keep coming back to the scene where Sanders tries to explain the intricacies of the two Maggie Moores to his bewildered deputy, Micah Stock’s character, who can't seem to grasp the sheer coincidence. It’s a moment that perfectly encapsulates the film's tone—a mix of genuine confusion and dry humor. Thematic keywords such as neo-nazism, the complications of an ex-husband, the tribulations of dating, the isolation of a widower, and even the everyday struggles of a diabetic are woven into the plot in ways that deepen the dark humor, rather than detract from it, exploring how these personal details become entangled in a larger, more sinister web that showcases the underbelly of a seemingly idyllic Arizona town. It's a bold choice, certainly. The film’s critical reception, with its 51% Rotten Tomatoes score, suggests that this blend didn't work for everyone, but for those who appreciate a crime story peppered with genuine laughs and a distinct authorial voice, it might just hit the mark.

Where to Stream Maggie Moore(s) Online

For those eager to dive into the darkly comedic mystery of Maggie Moore(s), the film is readily available across a diverse array of streaming platforms. Our comprehensive "Where to Watch" widget at the top of this page provides the most up-to-date information, but you'll find this R-rated gem currently streaming on services like Hulu, Prime Video (with or without ads), and Tubi TV. Viewers in regions served by Sky Go, Now TV Cinema, WOW, and Wow Fiction Amazon Channel also have access. For those who prefer transactional video on demand (TVOD), Maggie Moore(s) can be purchased or rented through popular digital storefronts such as Apple TV Store, Google Play Movies, YouTube, Fandango At Home, and Rakuten TV. European platforms like Canal VOD, Orange VOD, Premiere Max, Sooner, and VIVA by videofutur also list the film among their offerings. Plex and Plex Channel offer another avenue for viewing, giving audiences plenty of options to experience this unique crime caper. As Movie OTT constantly updates its database, you can be sure you're getting the latest availability information right here.

Frequently asked questions

Q: Is Maggie Moore(s) based on a true story?

Yes, Maggie Moore(s) is loosely based on the real-life murders of two women, Mary Lou Morris and Mary McGinnis Morris, which occurred in October 2000 in Houston, Texas. The film takes inspiration from these events to craft its darkly comedic mystery.

Q: Who directed Maggie Moore(s)?

The film Maggie Moore(s) was directed by John Slattery, an acclaimed actor known for his roles in Mad Men and Veep. This project sees him once again behind the camera, guiding the performances of Jon Hamm and Tina Fey.

Q: What is the IMDb rating for Maggie Moore(s)?

Maggie Moore(s) holds an IMDb rating of 6.2 out of 10, based on 10,443 user votes. This indicates a generally positive, though not overwhelmingly enthusiastic, reception from the audience.

Q: Where can I stream Maggie Moore(s) right now?

You can currently stream Maggie Moore(s) on platforms such as Hulu, Prime Video, Tubi TV, and Plex, among many others. Check the "Where to Watch" widget on this page for a complete and up-to-date list of all available streaming and rental options.

Final Verdict: Is Maggie Moore(s) Worth Your Time?

So, should you watch Maggie Moore(s)? If you’re a fan of dark comedy that doesn’t shy away from grim subject matter, or if you simply adore the on-screen chemistry between Jon Hamm and Tina Fey, then absolutely. It's not a flawless film—the mixed critical reception makes that clear—but it offers a uniquely quirky take on the crime mystery genre. The film manages to blend genuine suspense with laugh-out-loud moments, making it a compelling watch for those looking for something a bit different from the usual streaming fare. Fans of small-town secrets and neo-noir twists will find plenty to chew on, and the underlying "based on a true story" element adds an extra layer of intrigue. For a comprehensive guide to its availability, remember to consult Movie OTT.

Get the weekly digest

Hand-picked films new on Movie OTT. One email per week, no spam.

If this helped you decide what to watch, share it:

Share:
Advertisement
Rent or Buy Blockbuster Hits

You may also like

Picked by team & crew